Wants and needs

Image taken from the|G|™'s photostream on Flickr under Creative Commons License

I wrote about this in one of my first posts ‘More Baby’. Talking up the ‘nesting instinct’ almost advocates spending of thousands of dollars on things babies rarely need, and that will get little use.Nothing seems to bring out consumer culture more than new babies. And there have been lots of new babies popping out around me recently.

One of the challenges to consuming less for our babies and kids is the fact that there are some really clever ideas for kids products around lately. I don’t have a young baby and my youngest son is a very tall (almost) 4 year old. But I look at products like the bumbo seat and trunki’s and know that heck, I’d be tempted if I had a little tike. They are genuinely clever ideas.

The thing is, we seem to get confused between our wants and our needs. Young mums declare that they need‘ a bumbo for their 3 month old. The bumbo didn’t exist 4 years ago, so logic says it must be possible to raise children without possessing one.

On the positive side, there seems to be a fairly healthy culture of parents who buy these cool products and once they’ve finished using them (after all they have a very limited shelf life of about 9 months or less per child) pass them on to parents with younger children to use. If we can’t reduce the stuff we’re acquiring because we are so attracted by a product that we decide it’s a worthy investment, let’s at least ensure we reuse it.

By modelling the three r’s (reduce, reuse, recycle) we’re probably doing something as equally important for our kids as teaching them the other three r’s (reading, writing and arithmetic).

When I think about baby induced consumerism, I always think about one woman’s story I heard on the radio a year or so ago.

I cannot remember the name of the woman, but I think it was on ABC 702. She spoke about bringing her baby up in the country, possibly in the 1940s. She told the story of emptying out a drawer and putting a pillow in the bottom of it and using the drawer (never closed, but pulled out of the base) as a crib for her bub. It was a real turning point for me in thinking about wants and needs: for we can really make do with very little quite happily.

In real terms Australia is a wealthy country. And yet most of us go around thinking that we don’t have enough money to meet our ‘needs’. There is always another thing on our wish list. But do we really ‘need’ it to get by in life? Probably not. And I think it’s important to realise that.

I have a list of wants.

I’d really like to paint our lounge room, and paint the outside of our windows where the paint is dropping off in large flakes daily. I’d like to buy a water tank and some more solar panels. I’d love a new side gate so I could walk my bike out of it instead of wheeling it through the house every morning. I’d love to buy a few pairs of earrings I really love for my newly pierced ears (I blame my ‘thrisis’) and if I could ever find some I’d love to get a pair of delicate ballet flats, the kind that have elastic sides and look so comfy to wear (but that ain’t likely to happen anytime soon).

But I like the fact that they’re wants. They are not something I must have and have to have NOW. I’ll save for them. And maybe when the time comes, I’ll think they’re good to get. Or maybe I’ll decide I’d really rather go and take the family on a holiday instead.

It’s nice to think about needs and wants because you begin to realise what you have, instead of focussing on what you don’t have. And perhaps if we’re focussed on what we do have, we can do more to help others who genuinely don’t have.

I stumbled across the blog ‘The Everyday Minimalist’ this afternoon and this nice stream of thoughts on minimalism which kind of sums up some of the ideas I’ve had around cutting back to a more simple life.

A Minimalist’s Train of Thought

Less money spent means more money saved

More money saved means the longer you can live in financial peace and security

Financial peace and security comes from owning less

Less stuff owned means less to carry around, move or have to travel with

Less responsibility for your stuff also means less maintenance and more time

The more time you have, the more relaxed you will feel

The more relaxed you are, the less you will care about stuff

If you care less about stuff, it means you’ll care less about image

If you care less about image, you will care more about experiences and memories

If you care more about experiences and memories, you will be happier with less

If you are happier with less, you’ll never want or need for more

The less you want or need for more, the more you will feel free


What are your thoughts on distinguishing needs and wants?

And an interesting one – how do we get our children to understand needs and wants when they’re bombarded with advertising trying to get them to think they need the latest stuff?

My 6 year old is now asking for an iPhone when his parents don’t even own one! I’ve even had the tears rolling down his cheeks as I’ve told him we will definitely get him a phone when he’s in high school, and might think about it when he’s 10.

But on the promising side, I have been able to talk with him about identifying toys he no longer really uses to give away to boys and girls who don’t have many toys so they can have some special things to play with. He’s happy to engage in discussions about perhaps not ‘needing’ all the toys he has anymore. And it is lovely to see him actively putting himself in others shoes and being prepared to give to others.

So maybe the iPhone will not have the last laugh.

Image from http://www.flickr.com/photos/the-g-uk/3422469586/sizes/o/in/photostream/ with thanks to the|G|™.

About greenleftyidealist

Green, left and idealistic. A mum, a runner, a rogainer, a public servant and wanna be writer. My dog is golden.
This entry was posted in consumerism, society and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

1 Response to Wants and needs

  1. Carmen says:

    I love that minimalist’s train of thought, they are some great mantras. For me less stuff means less to clean, dust, move, put away, store. And you got to think – if it has been in a box untouched for 2 (or 5!) years; do you really need it?! Sometimes the clearing of physical space is just as therapeutic, if not more so, in ones mind. Whenever I am told ‘you need a cupboard or a shelf to put your stuff’ I think ‘no, I just need less stuff’. I have to remember that a lot because I am very often told I need more cupboards.

    When Jackson was a baby I wanted and was happy to place him in a washing basket with a pillow as a crib, and yet it was frowned apon (laughed at!) and I felt so much pressure around me. So I went and spent money I didn’t have on a cot he never slept in. And now at 8 he also wants an iphone 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s